## Overview **Time to Patch** measures the elapsed time from when a security vulnerability is disclosed (or detected) to when your team successfully deploys a patch to production. It's a critical metric for security posture, compliance, and risk management. ## Why It Matters - **Security risk**: Unpatched vulnerabilities are attack vectors - **Compliance**: Many regulations (SOC 2, PCI DSS, HIPAA) require timely patching - **Brand reputation**: Security breaches damage customer trust - **Financial impact**: Breaches are expensive (average $4.45M per incident) - **Legal liability**: Negligence in patching can lead to lawsuits - **Competitive advantage**: Strong security builds customer confidence ## Types of Vulnerabilities ### By Severity (CVSS Score) | Severity | CVSS Score | Target Time to Patch | Examples | |----------|-----------|-------------------|----------| | **Critical** | 9.0-10.0 | < 24 hours | Remote code execution, SQL injection | | **High** | 7.0-8.9 | < 7 days | Authentication bypass, privilege escalation | | **Medium** | 4.0-6.9 | < 30 days | XSS, information disclosure | | **Low** | 0.1-3.9 | < 90 days | Minor information leaks | ### By Source **Direct Dependencies:** - Libraries/packages your code imports directly - Easier to patch (update version in package.json) - Higher priority (directly exposed) **Transitive Dependencies:** - Dependencies of your dependencies - Harder to patch (may require upstream fixes) - Lower priority (indirect exposure) **Operating System:** - OS-level vulnerabilities - Patched through system updates - Infrastructure team responsibility **Container Images:** - Base image vulnerabilities - Requires rebuilding and redeploying containers - DevOps team responsibility ## How to Measure ### Timeline ``` Vulnerability Lifecycle: ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── Disclosure → Detection → Triage → Fix → Test → Deploy → Verify ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ CVE Alert Assess Code QA Prod Scan published fires priority change live clear │←─────────── Time to Patch ──────────────────────→│ ``` ### Calculation ``` Time to Patch = Deployment Time - Disclosure Time Example: - Vulnerability disclosed: Monday 9:00 AM - Patch deployed: Tuesday 2:00 PM - Time to Patch: 29 hours (1.2 days) Severity: Critical (CVSS 9.8) Status: ✓ Met 24-hour SLA ``` ### What to Track **Start Time (choose one):** - **Public disclosure**: CVE publication date (recommended) - **Detection**: When your scanner found it - **Notification**: When security team was alerted **End Time:** - **Production deployment**: When patch is live (recommended) - **Verification**: When vulnerability scan confirms fix ## Recommended Visualizations ### 1. Histogram by Severity **Best for**: Understanding patch time distribution ### 2. Trend Line (P50, P95 by Severity) **Best for**: Tracking improvement over time ### 3. Gauge (Current Status) **Best for**: Executive dashboards ## Target Ranges ### Industry Standards | Framework | Requirement | |-----------|------------| | **PCI DSS** | Critical: < 30 days, High: < 90 days | | **SOC 2** | Documented remediation timeline | | **HIPAA** | "Reasonable and appropriate" timeframe | | **NIST** | Critical: < 15 days, High: < 30 days | | **CIS** | Critical: < 15 days, High: < 30 days | ### Best Practice Targets | Severity | Target | Acceptable | Excellent | |----------|--------|-----------|-----------| | **Critical (9-10)** | < 24 hours | < 3 days | < 12 hours | | **High (7-8.9)** | < 7 days | < 14 days | < 3 days | | **Medium (4-6.9)** | < 30 days | < 60 days | < 14 days | | **Low (0-3.9)** | < 90 days | < 180 days | < 30 days | ### By Environment **Production (highest priority):** - Critical: < 24 hours - High: < 7 days **Staging:** - Critical: < 48 hours - High: < 14 days **Development:** - Lower priority, can be included in regular updates ## How to Improve ### 1. Automated Detection **Dependency Scanning:** ```yaml # GitHub Actions - Dependency scanning name: Security Scan on: [push, pull_request] jobs: security: runs-on: ubuntu-latest steps: - uses: actions/checkout@v3 - name: Run Snyk uses: snyk/actions/node@master env: SNYK_TOKEN: ${{ secrets.SNYK_TOKEN }} - name: Fail on high/critical run: | if [ "$SNYK_SEVERITY" == "critical" ] || [ "$SNYK_SEVERITY" == "high" ]; then exit 1 fi ``` **Continuous Monitoring:** - Snyk: Real-time monitoring of npm, PyPI, Maven, etc. - Dependabot: Automated PRs for vulnerable dependencies - WhiteSource: Enterprise security scanning - GitHub Security Advisories: Native GitHub alerts ### 2. Automated Patching **Auto-merge low-risk updates:** ```yaml # Dependabot auto-merge version: 2 updates: - package-ecosystem: "npm" directory: "/" schedule: interval: "daily" open-pull-requests-limit: 10 reviewers: - "security-team" # Auto-merge patch versions auto-merge: - dependency-name: "*" update-types: ["version-update:semver-patch"] ``` **Renovate Bot Configuration:** ```json { "extends": ["config:base"], "schedule": ["after 10pm every weekday"], "vulnerabilityAlerts": { "enabled": true, "labels": ["security", "priority-high"] }, "packageRules": [ { "matchUpdateTypes": ["patch"], "matchCurrentVersion": "!/^0/", "automerge": true } ] } ``` ### 3. Prioritization Framework **Decision Matrix:** ``` High Exploitability │ Low Exposure │ High Exposure Low Severity │ High Severity → Schedule │ → URGENT ────────────────────────┼──────────────────────── Low Exposure │ High Exposure High Severity │ Low Severity → Priority │ → Monitor │ Low Exploitability ``` **Triage Questions:** 1. **Severity**: What's the CVSS score? 2. **Exposure**: Is vulnerable code in production? 3. **Exploitability**: Is there a known exploit (exploit-db)? 4. **Mitigation**: Can we apply temporary mitigations? 5. **Fix availability**: Is a patch available? ### 4. Fast-Track Process **Emergency Patch Process:** 1. **Detect** (0-30 min): Automated alert fires 2. **Triage** (30-60 min): Security team assesses severity 3. **Fix** (1-4 hours): Update dependency version 4. **Test** (1-2 hours): Automated tests + smoke tests 5. **Deploy** (30 min): Fast-track deployment (skip non-critical checks) 6. **Verify** (30 min): Rescan to confirm fix **Total Time: 4-8 hours for critical vulnerabilities** ### 5. Reduce Dependencies **Minimize Attack Surface:** - Audit dependencies: Remove unused packages - Choose well-maintained libraries - Prefer dependencies with few transitive deps - Use dependency freeze for stable versions ```bash # Find unused dependencies npm-check -u # Audit dependency tree npm ls --all # Check for vulnerabilities npm audit ``` ## Common Pitfalls ### ❌ Ignoring Low Severity Vulnerabilities **Problem**: They pile up and become unmanageable **Solution**: Dedicate time each sprint to patch medium/low issues ### ❌ Waiting for Perfect Test Coverage **Problem**: Delays critical security patches **Solution**: Fast-track critical patches, add tests after if needed ### ❌ No Rollback Plan **Problem**: Bad patch takes down production **Solution**: Ensure rollback works before deploying security patches ### ❌ Patching Without Testing **Problem**: Breaking changes slip through **Solution**: Automated tests + smoke tests, even for urgent patches ### ❌ Not Tracking Transitive Dependencies **Problem**: Vulnerable indirect dependencies go unnoticed **Solution**: Use tools that scan full dependency tree ## Implementation Guide ### Week 1: Instrumentation ```bash # Install security scanning npm install --save-dev snyk # Run initial scan snyk test # Review vulnerabilities snyk monitor ``` ### Week 2: Establish Baselines - Document all current vulnerabilities - Calculate current time to patch (historical) - Set up alerting for new vulnerabilities - Define SLAs by severity ### Week 3: Automation ```yaml # CI/CD integration - name: Security Scan run: | snyk test --severity-threshold=high npm audit --audit-level=high ``` ### Week 4: Process - Create security runbook - Define on-call rotation for security issues - Establish communication channels (#security-alerts) - Document escalation procedures ## Dashboard Example ### Security Team View ``` ┌──────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │ Time to Patch (Critical Vulnerabilities) │ │ Average: 18 hours ✓ Under 24h SLA │ │ ██████████████████████░░░░░░░░░░ Good │ │ │ │ Open Vulnerabilities: │ │ • Critical (9-10): 2 ⚠️ URGENT │ │ • High (7-8.9): 8 ⚠️ Priority │ │ • Medium (4-6.9): 23 Monitor │ │ • Low (0-3.9): 45 Backlog │ │ │ │ This Month: │ │ • Patched: 12 vulnerabilities │ │ • Avg Time: 18 hours │ │ • SLA Compliance: 92% │ └──────────────────────────────────────────────┘ ``` ### Detailed View ``` Recent Critical Vulnerabilities ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────── CVE ID CVSS Package Detected Patched Time ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────── CVE-2024-1234 9.8 log4j Jan 15 Jan 15 8h ✓ CVE-2024-2345 9.1 axios Jan 20 Jan 21 22h ✓ CVE-2024-3456 9.0 express Jan 25 OPEN 72h ⚠️ ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────── Breakdown by Stage (Avg): Detection: 2 hours (11%) Triage: 3 hours (17%) Development: 8 hours (44%) Testing: 3 hours (17%) Deployment: 2 hours (11%) ──────────────────────── Total: 18 hours ``` ## Related Metrics - **Vulnerability Count**: How many open vulnerabilities? - **Exposure Time**: Days vulnerable code is in production - **Patch Coverage**: % of vulnerabilities patched vs. accepted risk - **Security Debt**: Accumulated unpatched vulnerabilities - **Deployment Frequency**: Ability to deploy patches quickly - **Change Failure Rate**: Quality of patches (do they break things?) ## Tools & Integrations ### Vulnerability Scanners - **Snyk**: Multi-language support, great GitHub integration - **Dependabot**: Free for GitHub, automatic PRs - **WhiteSource (Mend)**: Enterprise-grade, compliance focus - **Sonatype Nexus**: Java/Maven ecosystem - **GitHub Advanced Security**: Native GitHub scanning - **JFrog Xray**: Artifact scanning ### Container Scanning - **Trivy**: Fast, accurate, open-source - **Clair**: Container vulnerability scanning - **Anchore**: Policy-based container analysis - **Docker Scout**: Docker's official scanner ### OS/Infrastructure - **AWS Inspector**: EC2 and container scanning - **GCP Security Command Center**: GCP resource scanning - **Azure Security Center**: Azure resource scanning - **Wazuh**: Host-based intrusion detection ## Questions to Ask ### For Leadership - Are we meeting our SLAs for critical vulnerabilities? - Do we have unpatched critical vulnerabilities in production? - Are we compliant with security frameworks (PCI, SOC 2)? - Do we need to invest in faster deployment capabilities? ### For Security Teams - What's blocking us from patching faster? - Are dependencies up to date? - Do we have good test coverage for quick validation? - Are we monitoring all attack surfaces? ### For Engineering Teams - How quickly can we deploy an emergency patch? - Do we have a rollback plan? - Are we regularly updating dependencies? - Can we reduce our dependency count? ## Success Stories ### FinTech Startup - **Before**: 10-day average for critical patches - **After**: 8-hour average for critical patches - **Changes**: - Implemented automated dependency scanning - Fast-track deployment process for security patches - On-call security rotation - Pre-approved emergency change process - **Impact**: 94% reduction in time to patch, zero security incidents ### SaaS Platform - **Before**: 50+ unpatched high/critical vulnerabilities - **After**: 0 unpatched critical, avg 3 high vulnerabilities - **Changes**: - Dependabot auto-merge for patch versions - Security Champions program - Weekly vulnerability review meetings - 20% sprint capacity for dependency updates - **Impact**: Passed SOC 2 audit, customer trust improved ## Advanced Topics ### Zero-Day Vulnerabilities ``` Response Protocol: 1. Immediate assessment (< 1 hour) 2. Apply temporary mitigation (< 4 hours) 3. Monitor for exploit attempts 4. Deploy patch when available 5. Conduct post-incident review ``` ### Supply Chain Attacks - Verify package integrity (checksums, signatures) - Use private registries for critical dependencies - Implement Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) - Monitor for suspicious dependency updates ### Bug Bounty Programs - Coordinate disclosure with security researchers - Have clear patching SLAs in policy - Communicate fixes to researchers - Track time to patch for bounty submissions ## Conclusion Time to Patch is a critical security metric that measures your organization's ability to respond to vulnerabilities. Elite teams patch critical vulnerabilities within 24 hours through automated detection, fast-track processes, and high deployment frequency. Start measuring today, automate vulnerability detection, establish clear SLAs by severity, and practice emergency patch procedures. Remember: every hour a critical vulnerability remains unpatched increases your risk exponentially. **Quick Start Checklist:** - [ ] Install vulnerability scanner (Snyk, Dependabot) - [ ] Run initial scan, document baseline - [ ] Set up automated alerts for new vulnerabilities - [ ] Define SLAs by severity - [ ] Create fast-track patch process - [ ] Practice emergency patch deployment - [ ] Measure and track time to patch

Risk

Featured

Time to Patch (Security Vulnerabilities)

All Risk

Want to contribute?